Natural reforestation on the abandoned arable lands is one of the characteristic processes that triggers the transformation of soils, accompanied by the change in the abundance, biomass, and taxonomic structure of the soil macrofauna. The assessment of the restoration potential of the soil properties and soil macrofauna to the natural state, the duration of this period, the dynamics of soil organic carbon stocks, and the role of macrofauna in this process at different stages of post-agrogenic successions is relevant for prediction of changes in ecosystem components and their role in the storage of organic carbon under various land use scenarios. The work is based on the data on organic carbon reserves, morphological properties of soils, abundance, biomass and taxonomic structure of the soil macrofauna of arable lands, primary forests and 5 stages of pine forest restoration (fallow meadows and pine forests of different ages) at the Smolenskoye Poozerye National Park (Smolensk region). It was revealed that in the soils of the 85–100-year-old pine forests, signs of plowing are preserved in the form of the smooth lower boundary of the humus horizon. At the same time, signs of soil regradation appear already at the meadow stage and are expressed in the formation of a thin humus horizon penetrated by roots, which transforms further at the next stages. In the litter and mineral part of the soil, the carbon stocks change non-monotonically with a maximum at the meadow stage and a minimum in 70–80-year-old forests. By the age of 80, the stock of organic carbon in the mineral part of soils is almost restored to the background values. The composition of soil macrofauna changes drastically during the transition from meadow to forest communities. At the initial stages (in agrocenoses and fallow meadows), the fauna of mineral soil horizons predominates: endogeic earthworms and larvae of lamellar beetles. Further, the fauna of organic horizons is restored, among which there is a high proportion of saprophages – epigeic and epi-endogeic earthworms, which contribute to the differentiation of litter. The biomass of saprophages has a negative correlation with the carbon reserves in the mineral part of forest soils, the thickness and reserves of organic carbon in the litter, and a positive correlation with the share of the easily decomposable litter fraction.